|
Post by mitch9234 on Sept 1, 2012 18:17:00 GMT -5
No rookie should be higher than 80. Heck, I'd put the best rookie at 75. If we were to grade rookies' performances with Madden Ratings, then Cam Newton's performance in his rookie season wasn't lower than 80, Von Miller wasn't as well
|
|
|
Post by mitch9234 on Sept 1, 2012 18:22:39 GMT -5
What does it mean when a player has a question mark besides his overall in Madden?
|
|
|
Post by Jindred on Sept 1, 2012 18:40:33 GMT -5
@mitch Luck is a rookie! He is Overrated cause he hasn't played a snap in the NFL and is somehow rated better than QBs who have. Mainly Andy Dalton which bothers the crap out of me. Collie LOL Collie is good.. if only he could go two seconds without getting a concussion! But he still has yet to prove he is any better than that because well.. we haven't seen him do anything! I agree with the rest Maybe because they think he'll be better than Dalton Had 8 TDs in half of the season in 2010, if he played the whole season he would have a monster season and would continue to shine even with a rookie QB, was Luck's favorite target in training camp and can lead the Colts in receiving TDs and receptions Doesn't matter if they think he will be, the simple fact is at this very moment he isn't because he hasn't played a single snap in a real NFL game. Andy Dalton has and did quite well! There is no way Luck RG3 or any rookie should be better then him.
|
|
|
Post by Panther on Sept 1, 2012 18:43:33 GMT -5
No rookie should be higher than 80 BEFORE the season
|
|
|
Post by mitch9234 on Sept 1, 2012 18:45:28 GMT -5
No rookie should be higher than 80 BEFORE the season ah you didn't clear that up lol
|
|
|
Post by MarchingOn on Sept 1, 2012 21:13:58 GMT -5
@mo Your running backs are all rated about right. Except Pierre Thomas he should only be 80 IMO Lance Moore is Overrated. Bushrod is fine IMO Strieff is too low if anything. Will Smith is about right. Barrett Ruud to high? really? He is a very good MLB and the only reason he isn't mid 80s low 90s is because he has been so injury prone all his career 78 is perfect for him. I agree with the rest except Johnny Patrick cause I don't know who he is lol. Oh I also think Curtis Lofton is underrated should be a 93 IMO. No. I can understand Ingram being below 80, I actually think he is perfect at 79 for the time being. But the rest should be above. I am ready to argue this. How is Moore overrated? Smith used to be good, but he is getting old and didn't do that good last year. Point taken on Ruud Johnny Patrick is our 3nd round pick from 2011. He's better than a 68, but I wouldn't upgrade him too much. I think 71 is fair for him.
|
|
|
Post by MarchingOn on Sept 1, 2012 21:14:49 GMT -5
Smith is too high IMO. Jindred, Patrick is a rookie CB. Remember someone saying he'll enjoy picking off Drew Brees? Well that was Patrick No, that was Corey White.
|
|
|
Post by Panther on Sept 1, 2012 21:48:40 GMT -5
Okay, Thanks MO.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 1, 2012 22:36:44 GMT -5
Talking about the roster highs and lows, I think I didn't do mine for the Colts yet Indianapolis Colts QB Andrew Luck - 84HB Donald Brown - 78 HB Mewelde Moore - 73 HB Delone Carter - 71 FB Kyle Miller - 55 WR Reggie Wayne - 88 WR Austin Collie - 78WR Donnie Avery - 71 WR T.Y. Hilton - 65TE Coby Fleener - 75 TE Dwayne Allen - 71 LT Anthony Castonzo - 77 LG Joe Reitz - 73 C Samson Satele - 83 RG Mike McGlynn - 76 RG Ben Ijalana - 75 RT Winston Justice - 77LE Cory Redding - 88 RE Drake Nevis - 73RE Fili Moala - 71DT Antonio Johnson - 71DT Brandon McKinney - 71 DT Josh Chapman - 68 LOLB Robert Mathis - 88 LOLB Moise Fokou - 71 MLB Pat Angerer - 80 MLB Kavell Conner - 73 ROLB Dwight Freeney - 90 CB Jerraud Powers - 80 CB Cassius Vaughn - 71CB Justin King - 69 CB Chris Rucker - 69 CB Josh Gordy - 68 FS Antoine Bethea - 91 SS Tom Zbikowski - 80 K Adam Vinatieri - 88 P Pat McAfee - 84 OverratedUnderratedSlightly underratedSuper Duper Ultra Mega UnderratedI agree with Hilton being underrated but disagree with Luck. I think Luck is too high.
|
|
bigd51
NFL Draft pick
[insert witty title here]
I'm always angry
Posts: 1,073
|
Post by bigd51 on Sept 2, 2012 0:36:43 GMT -5
What does it mean when a player has a question mark besides his overall in Madden? I can only assume that the players you are referring to are rookies after the draft has taken place b/c those are the only players I've seen that ever have question marks beside any of their ratings. If they're rookies, the reason why they have question marks beside their OVR ratings is b/c you haven't fully unlocked ALL of their individual ratings yet... therefor the OVR rating for that player is just an estimate (hence the question mark) based on the individual ratings you have fully unlocked at that time that are relevant to the position he plays. That's the only reason I know of, though, so hopefully I didn't just waste 10 minutes telling you something you already knew
|
|